|
by Karen Ocamb
Every four years, before the presidential election, the
political parties draft a platform that defines their core
values, policy goals and aspirations. Though generally not
read in depth by the voting public, the platform nonetheless
stands as an official statement against which the statements
and actions of candidates can be measured.
This year both the Republican and Democratic parties made
history in their different approaches to writing the platform:
The GOP has a participatory questionnaire about issues online,
while the Democrats held 1,600 listening sessions seeking
input around the country and abroad, many of which involved
state chapters of the National Stonewall Democrats and other
LGBT groups.
Another historic first for the Democrats was the appointment
by Democratic National Committee Chair Howard Dean of HIV/AIDS
activist Diego Sanchez, co-chair of the Massachusetts Transgender
Political Coalition, to the 186-member Platform Committee.
The “comprehensive platform is an historic landmark,” Sanchez
told reporters and bloggers on an Aug. 11 conference call
organized by National Stonewall Democrats, who have been
working closely with the DNC through their Pride in the Party
program. The platform “shows the party’s desire and its readiness
for inclusion, and it shows its leaders’ focus on leaving
no one behind. The platform feels inclusive both in its content
and its intent.”
Congressmember Tammy Baldwin, who was on the first platform
drafting committee in Cleveland, told reporters that the
platform “is truly historic in going further than any previous
platform has done, particularly on LGBT equality.”
The platform, Baldwin said, “makes very clear that our party
rejects discrimination based on a wide range of issues, but
including—very explicitly—race, gender, religion, sexual
orientation and gender identity. … For the first time in
the history of our party, the platform stands for the inclusion
in the life of the nation for transgendered Americans. It
explicitly lists gender identity as a protected category.”
Baldwin and Alabama state Rep. Patricia Todd, who served
on the platform committee that passed an amended platform
on Aug. 9 in Pittsburgh, said that inclusionary language
was strengthened throughout the process. For instance, same-sex
couples were added to the family section, so it now reads:
“We support full inclusion of all families, including same-sex
couples, in the life of our nation.”
The platform is also the strongest ever, Baldwin said, going
beyond the historic inclusionary process and language to
provide context and philosophy to substantial policy goals.
“It’s not just the rhetoric on inclusion, which we have seen
weaker language in previous platforms,” Baldwin said. “This
platform is made particularly strong because as we go from
rhetoric to policy and substance [that] reflect the positions
that have been courageous championed by Senator Obama. So
it goes far beyond opposition to the Federal Marriage Amendment,
which we saw in the 2004 platform, and repealing ‘Don’t Ask,
Don’t Tell.’ This year’s platform shows that Democrats are
committed to enacting hate crime legislation, enacting a
comprehensive [bipartisan] Employment Non-Discrimination
Act, opposing the Defense of Marriage Act and attempts to
use same-sex marriage in a divisive manner.”
Aubrey Sarvis, executive director of the Servicemembers Legal
Defense Network, which was created to fight the “Don’t Ask,
Don’t Tell” policy, told reporters that, “Four years ago,
it was very hard to find mention of ‘Don't Ask, Don't Tell’
in the platform. This year, the statement is bold and unequivocal.”
In fact, the platform calls not only for the repeal of DADT,
but proactively, Baldwin noted, for “implementing policies
to allow qualified men and women to serve openly regardless
of their sexual orientation.”
The platform also calls for a national strategy to fight
HIV/AIDS domestically, as well as globally—something pushed
for by Dr. Marjorie Hill, executive director of the Gay Men’s
Health Crisis in New York, and Phill Wilson, executive director
of the Los Angeles-based Black AIDS Institute. There is no
mention of defunding the Bush administration’s abstinence-based
prevention efforts, however.
Several reporters questioned the omission of the specific
words “gay,” “lesbian,” “bisexual” and “transgender” from
the document. Freelance political reporter Lisa Keen asked
why that was so, since Obama has appeared so comfortable
with the word “gay.” Was there conscious discussion about
omitting the words, lest Republicans “go through the platform
with a fine tooth comb?”
“I can say that is absolutely not true,” Todd said. “There
was never any discussion about keeping it out. We were trying
to be very clear on the particular policy issues we were
talking about—sometimes it is ‘gender identify,’ and sometimes
it is ‘same-sex couples.’”
Jon Hoadley, executive director of National Stonewall Democrats,
said, “We actually tried to find language that was more inclusive
… Adding language about same-sex couples is exactly that
because it doesn’t just mean gay or lesbian couples,” it
can also refer to transgender couples or if one person is
bisexual. “All those families are included in this document.”
Additionally, the intention was to “model” language used
in legislation so the platform can be used by candidates
in their races. ENDA, for instance, uses the categories of
sexual orientation and gender identity rather than specifying
“gay, lesbian, bisexual or transgender.” And the platform
does not refer to civil unions but “support equal responsibility,
benefits and protections” for same-sex couples.
“We were certainly wordsmithing on how to make sure that
we were clear on the various policies issues that affect
the LGBT community—that we were having the most inclusive
language possible,” said Baldwin. “We were talking about
doing what’s right, and that was a heartwarming part of the
process for me.”
Baldwin noted an obvious but too often overlooked point when
pressed on the fact that the platform does not go beyond
stating opposition to using same-sex marriage as a “divisive
issue,” with anti-gay ballot measures on the ballot in three
states in November—California, Arizona and Florida.
“The platform is not an action plan, an implementation plan,”
Baldwin told IN Los Angeles magazine. “Rather, it is the
reflection of the values and beliefs and policy positions
of this party. It’s up to us as members of the Democratic
Party to carry those out and bring actions to these very
important calls.”
Karl Rove, the “architect” of using anti-gay initiatives
in swing states to bring out religious conservatives to vote
for George W. Bush in 2000 and 2004, told the Los Angeles
Times recently that same-sex marriage would not be as important
an issue in 2008.
“It has a lower profile, but it will be an issue in people’s
minds,” Rove said. “The bigger issues will be the economy,
terrorism, healthcare, energy.” But, he said, “values always
play a role in a campaign.”
It’s a point the Family Research Council and former Arkansas
Gov. Mike Huckabee have been driving home in advance of the
“Values Voter Summit” in Washington, D.C., during which religious
conservatives hope to press presumptive GOP presidential
candidate John McCain on social issues such as same-sex marriage
and abortion rights. Religious conservatives are particularly
worried that the pro-life McCain might select former Homeland
Security Secretary, Tom Ridge, as his running mate, since
Ridge is pro-choice.
Other national political figures in McCain’s camp also disagree
on social issues. California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger,
for instance, opposes Prop. 8, the anti-gay ballot initiative
in California, which McCain supports. However, Florida Gov.
Charlie Crist, another vice-presidential hopeful, has endorsed
the anti-gay initiative in his state.
The platform also clarifies Obama’s version of a faith-based
social services program that would ensure partnerships with
religious organizations “do not endanger First Amendment
protections and that public funds are not used to proselytize
or discriminate.”
The platform will be approved during the Democratic convention
Aug. 23-29.
|