|
BY MICHAEL KEARNS
Watch Your Language, Mary

“You must be a wordsmith,” my friend said, a
tad facetiously, when I described some voluptuous male creature
in baggy fatigue pants-maybe gay, maybe not-as “an
insouciant punk.” Wordsmith? It's not a very desirable
characterization, is it? But it's true, I am in love with
words. As a kid, when most boys my age were perfecting their
football skills, I was sweating over a precious haiku.
How will words and phrases-from “gay marriage,” to “Don't
Ask, Don't Tell,” to the EDNA bill-affect us as a community
as we stumble into the New Year?
Let's return to the abovementioned phrase: “maybe gay,
maybe not.” The meaning of gay has morphed dramatically.
Could anyone describe “a gay old time” without
eliciting a raised eyebrow or two?
Yet words change their meaning, often transmogrifying before
our very ears.
Synonymous with “homosexual” more often than “jovial,” the
word “gay”—according to the online urban
dictionary—“is often used to describe something
stupid or unfortunate…originating from homophobia…preferable
among many teenage males in order to buff up their masculinity.” The
online dictionary devoted to slang cites an example: “Man,
these seats are gay. I can't even see what's going on!”
In my day, that sentence would have meant that there were
some studs with hot butts wearing tight jeans that were distracting
from the view.
When Congressman Larry Craig insists that he's “not
gay,” I tend to agree. He's not gay in the way that
we envisioned gay back in the late ‘60s when those
heroic drag queens and leathermen pounced on the cops at
the Stonewall Inn: an act of sedition that marked the beginning
of gay liberation. He's not gay and proud. Or gay and loud.
Craig is a closet case, not to be confused with being a gay
man.
Even though the word has morphed, it remains very much a
part of this country's political discourse. Just listen to
the ponderous politicians on the subject of “gay marriage.” Even
that expression, the alchemy of two somewhat indefinable
words, seems stodgy. However, “civil union” makes “gay
marriage sound” almost warm and fuzzy. When it comes
to pinpointing a precise meaning, “gay marriage” is
a bit like “gay adoption”—a teaming of
words that is wildly interpretive. Gay adoption could mean
that you're caring for a child who is the reincarnation of
Charles Nelson Reilly.
Words define us, influence us, frighten us, trigger us, commit
us, embarrass us, entangle us, confuse us, seduce us. Words
ignite. Words can start a war, spur an orgasm; they comprise
wedding vows and divorce papers, romantic lyrics, and hate
mail.
Consider how words determine our cultural legacy as well
as our present fluctuating legal rights. “Don't ask,
don't tell” portends considerably more consequence
than the line, “Mary, don't ask” that was popularized
by the 1968 theatrical phenomenon, The Boys In The Band.
At the end of '07, according to the Los Angeles Times, “A
group of 28 retired generals and admirals made public a letter
to Congress urging complete repeal of “Don't Ask, Don't
Tell.” After 14 years, it now seems all but certain
that the unpopular policy is in its last throes.”
Yet, the Military Readiness Enhancement Act is stalled in
the House and has no counterpoint in the Senate. While Democratic
presidential contenders say they oppose the current policy, “few
have explicitly backed it,” the Times reports.
Another bill, the Employment Nondiscrimination Act, was initially
conceived to protect the GLBT community in the workplace
(from verbal abuse to other forms of prejudicial treatment).
But, fearing that the bill may be too strident for the general
public, the “T” in GLBT (a hard-won acronym that
stands for Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Transgender) has been
dropped.
“There are workplace situations—communal showers,
for example—when the demands of the transgender community
fly in the face of conventional norms, and therefore would
not pass in any Congress,” says Barney Frank who championed
the ENDA bill.
“I've talked with transgender activists and what they
want…is for people with penises who identify as women
to be able to shower with other women,” Frank asserts.
So here's a question: Will the day arrive when a person with
a penis who identifies as a woman be able to go into the
military?
Sergeant, don't ask.
|